Dana Satterfield Murder: How DNA Solved the 10-Year Cold Case

On July 31, 1995, 27-year-old hair stylist Dana Satterfield was murdered inside her salon in Roebuck, South Carolina. A woman saw a young man escape through a window shortly after the killing. Police also recovered DNA evidence from the crime scene. Yet, neither clue led to an arrest for years.

Investigators initially questioned Dana’s husband and later considered several other suspects. One man even identified the suspected killer, only for DNA testing to rule him out.

The case remained unsolved for a decade. Then, in 2005, a man who had kept a secret for years finally came forward. His information helped police identify the person responsible for Dana’s murder.

Who Was Dana Satterfield?

Dana Satterfield was a 27-year-old hair stylist who lived and worked in Roebuck, South Carolina. She owned a small salon inside a converted trailer located between a gas station and a liquor store.

Despite its unusual location, the salon had become popular in the community. Dana had many regular customers, including local mothers and teenagers.

She worked long hours, often starting at 9:00 a.m. and continuing into the evening. Her husband, Mike, usually stayed home to look after their two children while she worked.

However, her personal life was not going as well as her business. Dana was considering divorce and had already contacted a lawyer. She planned to meet with him on August 1, 1995.

That meeting would never happen.

What Happened on July 31, 1995?

Dana’s Last Appointment

At around 7:00 p.m. on Monday, July 31, Dana was cutting a customer’s hair when a saleswoman named Diane Harris entered the salon.

Diane had spent the afternoon selling cleaning products door-to-door. Dana had allowed her inside and even purchased a bottle of cleaner, mainly because she disliked turning people away.

After a brief conversation, Diane left the salon.

Dana continued working on her final customer. Around 8:10 p.m., she finished the haircut and removed the cape from the customer’s shoulders.

The customer offered to stay with Dana until she was ready to leave. She knew Dana sometimes received unwanted attention from male customers and thought they could walk out together for safety.

Dana politely declined the offer.

After the customer left, Dana turned the sign on the front door to show that the salon was closed. She then began sweeping the hair from the floor.

A Man Escaped Through the Salon Window

A short time later, Diane Harris was walking past the salon again.

Although the front blinds were closed, she noticed that the lights were still on. As she passed the building, she suddenly heard a loud thump from inside.

She stopped and looked toward the salon.

Then a small window on the side of the trailer opened. Its screen fell to the ground, and a young man climbed outside.

He wore a gray shirt and blue jeans. Diane described him as a young white man who appeared to be in his twenties.

The two made eye contact.

Diane began screaming. The man looked frightened and immediately ran toward a nearby gas station.

Diane ran in the opposite direction until she reached a house with its lights on. She knocked on the door and asked the homeowner to call the police.

Police Discover Dana Satterfield’s Body

Around 8:45 p.m., Deputy John Burnett of the Spartanburg County Sheriff’s Department received a report about a possible break-in at the salon.

He was the closest officer and quickly arrived at the scene.

The front door was partly open. Burnett entered carefully and called out, but nobody answered.

At first, the salon appeared empty. However, when he reached a small room at the back, he discovered something horrifying.

Dana was dead.

She had been tied to a water heater with a strap wrapped around her neck. Her clothing was covered in blood, and her body showed signs of severe injuries.

The room contained a toilet, washing machine, dryer, and water heater. Blood spatter covered the surrounding area.

Burnett immediately contacted dispatch and reported what he had found.

The Cause of Death

The following morning, homicide detective Rick Gregory reviewed photographs from the crime scene.

Investigators determined that Dana had been severely beaten and strangled. They also suspected that she had been sexually assaulted.

Her body had been left tied to the water heater by her neck.

Interestingly, the killer had not taken anything from the salon. Dana’s purse and the money in the cash box were still there.

This made robbery an unlikely motive.

The brutality of the attack suggested that the killer might have had a personal reason for targeting her.

Why Police Initially Suspected Dana’s Husband

Detective Gregory discovered an important detail while reviewing Dana’s appointment planner.

It showed that Dana had scheduled a meeting with a divorce lawyer for the following day.

Since her final customer had left around 8:10 p.m. and Diane had seen the man escaping shortly afterward, investigators placed the likely time of death between approximately 8:10 and 8:30 p.m.

Gregory decided to question Dana’s husband, Mike.

Mike’s Unusual Behavior at the Crime Scene

Mike arrived at the salon while police were collecting evidence. According to reports from officers at the scene, he tried to force his way inside.

Several deputies had to restrain him.

During his interview on August 1, 1995, Mike was extremely emotional. He cried while talking about Dana and described her as someone who was loved by everyone.

When Gregory asked about their marriage, Mike said they had been working through some problems.

He appeared surprised when the detective told him that Dana had planned to meet a divorce lawyer.

Mike claimed he did not know about the appointment. He also said that even if she had spoken to a lawyer, it did not mean their marriage was about to end.

Mike Had an Alibi

Despite his suspicious behavior and possible marital problems, investigators faced two important obstacles.

First, Diane had described the escaping man as a relatively young and slim individual, weighing around 170 pounds. Mike was 33 years old and weighed more than 300 pounds.

Second, Mike had been at home with his children during the estimated time of the murder.

He also voluntarily agreed to provide fingerprints and a blood sample and take a polygraph test.

He passed the first polygraph examination.

These details made it difficult for investigators to establish that Mike had personally committed the murder.

However, they continued examining his possible involvement.

The Investigation Reaches a Dead End

A Fingerprint Found on the Water Heater

About a week after the murder, the forensic laboratory delivered two important findings.

First, investigators had recovered male DNA from Dana’s body.

Second, they had identified a fingerprint on the water heater. The print appeared to match Mike’s fingerprints.

This was significant because the water heater was where Dana’s body had been found.

Detective Gregory called Mike back for another interview.

Mike explained that he had installed the water heater himself just a few weeks before Dana’s murder. He said this was why his fingerprint was there.

Investigators found the timing suspicious but had no immediate way to disprove his explanation.

Mike agreed to take another polygraph test. He again denied killing Dana or knowing about any plan to kill her. The test indicated that he was telling the truth.

Gregory knew polygraph tests were not foolproof. However, Mike had passed twice, had an alibi, and did not match the physical description of the man seen escaping.

The detective had to look elsewhere.

The Blue and White SUV

During their neighborhood investigation, police received information about a distinctive blue and white SUV seen near Dana’s salon on the night of the murder.

Investigators believed the vehicle might belong to the killer.

They released its description to the public, along with a composite sketch of the man Diane had seen leaving the salon.

The information attracted considerable attention. Police received several calls from people who believed they had seen the vehicle.

One local woman, Mary Ann Vick, repeatedly attracted police attention because she drove a similar SUV.

She even complained to the press that officers were harassing her because of her vehicle.

Detective Gregory checked Dana’s appointment planner and discovered that Mary Ann was one of Dana’s regular customers.

Mary Ann also had a 17-year-old son named Jonathan.

His age was close enough to the witness’s description to make him worth investigating, although he was younger than the man Diane had described.

The Witness Rules Out Mary Ann’s SUV

Gregory contacted the witness who had originally reported seeing the blue and white SUV.

He asked the man to accompany him to Mary Ann Vick’s house.

When they arrived, they saw a blue and white SUV parked in the driveway.

The witness walked around the vehicle and carefully examined its grille and wheels.

But he shook his head.

He said it was not the same SUV he had seen outside Dana’s salon.

This appeared to eliminate another possible lead. Investigators moved on without knowing how important the connection to the Vick family would eventually become.

DNA Testing Rules Out Mike

A few months later, the crime laboratory completed its analysis of the male DNA recovered from Dana’s body.

Investigators compared the profile with Mike’s DNA.

The results showed that Mike was not a match.

This was a major setback for the investigation. Although police could not completely rule out the possibility that he had arranged the crime, they had no evidence connecting his DNA to the assault.

The case remained open, but the investigation had reached another dead end.

Russell Quinn Becomes a Suspect in 1997

Two years after Dana’s murder, Detective Gregory received an interesting tip from a local jail.

An inmate claimed that his cellmate, Russell Quinn, carried a photograph of Dana and bragged about assaulting her.

Gregory was cautious. Prisoners sometimes made false claims to impress other inmates or gain advantages in their own cases.

However, Russell’s background gave the detective reasons to investigate further.

Two details stood out:

  • Russell had been working within a few miles of Dana’s salon on the night of the murder.
  • He was believed to have stolen a blue and white SUV just days before Dana was killed.

These details seemed to connect him to both the crime scene and the vehicle described by witnesses.

Diane Harris Identifies Russell Quinn

In 1997, investigators showed Diane Harris photographs of several men who matched her original description of the escaping man.

One of the photographs showed Russell Quinn.

Diane studied the photographs carefully. Eventually, she pointed to Russell and identified him as the man she had seen climbing out of Dana’s salon window.

For Detective Gregory, this appeared to be the breakthrough he had been waiting for.

Russell had a possible connection to the stolen vehicle, had been nearby on the night of the murder, and had now been identified by an eyewitness.

But the forensic evidence told a different story.

DNA Excludes Russell Quinn

About a week later, the crime laboratory informed Gregory that Russell’s DNA did not match the DNA recovered from Dana’s body.

Despite the eyewitness identification and other suspicious circumstances, investigators could not establish that Russell was the killer.

His claims about assaulting Dana also appeared to have been false.

The case remained unsolved.

Years Pass Without a Breakthrough

Over the following years, Detective Gregory continued investigating Dana’s murder.

He considered whether she might have had a stalker. He also asked the FBI to develop a psychological profile of the killer.

However, neither effort produced a reliable new suspect.

Investigators had several important pieces of evidence:

  • A witness who had seen the killer escaping through a window.
  • A physical description of the suspect.
  • A description of a blue and white SUV.
  • Male DNA recovered from the crime scene.

Yet none of these clues had led to a confirmed identification.

The DNA did not match Mike or Russell Quinn. The witness had also rejected Mary Ann Vick’s SUV when she examined it in daylight.

By this point, Gregory had little reason to believe the case would ever be solved.

But in 2005, ten years after Dana’s death, someone finally came forward with information that changed everything.

A Witness Comes Forward in 2005

One afternoon in 2005, Detective Gregory received a call from a man who wanted to discuss Dana Satterfield’s murder.

The man introduced himself as Michael Pace. He worked as a mechanic at a local gas station.

A few days earlier, a young woman had brought her vehicle to the station for an oil change.

When Michael saw her, he was shocked by how much she resembled Dana.

After she left, another employee told him that the woman was Dana’s 18-year-old daughter.

The encounter brought back memories that Michael had kept hidden for a decade.

He had known something important about Dana’s murder since 1995. But he had remained silent because he was afraid.

Now, seeing Dana’s daughter had made him feel guilty about keeping the secret.

He decided to speak to police.

What Michael Pace Told Investigators

Michael explained that he had been friends with Jonathan Vick, the son of Dana’s regular customer, Mary Ann Vick.

In the summer of 1995, Jonathan had told Michael that he was romantically interested in Dana.

He said he planned to visit her salon that evening and ask her out.

But Jonathan’s plans ended in a murder.

A few days after Dana was killed, Jonathan allegedly pulled Michael aside and threatened to kill him if he ever told anyone about their earlier conversation.

Michael was frightened by the threat and kept quiet.

For ten years, he carried the secret.

Seeing Dana’s daughter brought back the memories and made him reconsider his silence.

He finally told Detective Gregory everything he knew.

Michael’s statement gave investigators a new direction and helped them understand how Jonathan Vick might have been connected to the crime.

How Jonathan Vick Killed Dana Satterfield

Based on the witness statements and crime scene evidence, investigators reconstructed what they believed happened on July 31, 1995.

Jonathan Arrives at the Salon

A little after 8:00 p.m., Jonathan Vick drove his mother’s blue and white SUV to a secluded parking area near Dana’s salon.

He got out and walked across the street toward the building.

The salon was already closed. Dana was alone, sweeping hair from the floor.

Jonathan entered without knocking.

Dana initially appeared surprised but politely told him that the salon was closed and he would have to return another time.

However, Jonathan was not there for a haircut.

He told Dana that he wanted to be with her and believed she felt the same way.

Dana rejected his advances and made it clear that she was not interested.

The Attack

Jonathan became angry after Dana rejected him.

He suddenly attacked her, knocking her to the ground. He then dragged her into the small room at the back of the salon.

There, he brutally beat and sexually assaulted her.

He took a strap from a bag in the main salon area, wrapped it around Dana’s neck, and strangled her.

After killing her, he used the strap to fasten her body to the water heater.

He then realized that he needed to escape.

Diane Harris Sees the Killer

Jonathan decided not to leave through the front door.

Instead, he opened the small side window, removed the screen, and climbed outside.

But he had not noticed Diane Harris walking past the salon.

She saw him emerge from the window. The two made eye contact, and Diane immediately started screaming.

Jonathan ran toward the nearby gas station and returned to his vehicle.

When he reached home, he reportedly checked the inside of the SUV for blood before going inside. He was worried that his mother would discover what he had done with her vehicle.

The man Diane had seen escaping was Jonathan Vick, not Russell Quinn.

DNA Evidence Finally Identifies the Killer

After Michael Pace provided his information, investigators focused on Jonathan Vick.

They obtained a DNA sample from him and compared it with the male DNA recovered from Dana’s body in 1995.

This time, the results provided the breakthrough police had needed.

Jonathan Vick’s DNA matched the DNA recovered from the crime scene.

The forensic evidence supported Michael’s account and connected Jonathan directly to the murder.

On October 24, 2005, Jonathan Vick was arrested.

He had been 17 years old when Dana was murdered.

Jonathan Vick’s Conviction and Sentence

A little over a year after his arrest, Jonathan Vick was convicted of Dana Satterfield’s murder and sexual assault.

He was sentenced to life in prison.

After ten years of investigation, Dana’s family finally had an answer about who had killed her.

The case had involved several false leads, an innocent husband under suspicion, a misleading eyewitness identification, and years of unanswered questions.

Ultimately, DNA evidence and a witness who decided to speak out helped bring the investigation to an end.

What Made the Dana Satterfield Case So Difficult to Solve?

The investigation lasted ten years because several pieces of evidence initially pointed in different directions.

1. Suspicion Fell on the Wrong People

Dana’s planned divorce raised questions about her husband. His fingerprint on the water heater also attracted attention.

However, his DNA did not match the crime scene evidence.

2. The SUV Description Was Misleading

Police received several tips about blue and white SUVs. Mary Ann Vick’s vehicle appeared to match the description, but the original witness initially rejected it.

The connection between the vehicle and Jonathan Vick was not properly established until Michael Pace came forward.

3. The Wrong Suspect Was Identified

Diane Harris identified Russell Quinn in a photographic lineup.

However, DNA testing excluded him as the source of the recovered male DNA.

This demonstrated how an eyewitness identification, even when made with confidence, can be mistaken.

4. A Witness Remained Silent for Ten Years

Michael Pace knew about Jonathan’s interest in Dana and the events leading up to the murder.

But Jonathan’s threat prevented him from speaking to police.

His decision to come forward in 2005 finally gave investigators the missing information.

5. DNA Evidence Took Time to Lead to the Killer

Investigators recovered male DNA in 1995, but they initially had no matching suspect.

It was only after Jonathan became a suspect that police obtained a matching DNA sample.

The combination of forensic evidence and Michael’s testimony helped bring the case to a successful conclusion.

Timeline of the Dana Satterfield Murder Case

DateImportant event
July 31, 1995Dana Satterfield is murdered in her salon
August 1, 1995Police question her husband, Mike
1995Investigators recover male DNA and a fingerprint from the crime scene
1997Russell Quinn becomes a suspect but is excluded by DNA testing
2005Michael Pace comes forward with information
October 24, 2005Jonathan Vick is arrested
2006Jonathan Vick is convicted and sentenced to life in prison

Conclusion

The murder of Dana Satterfield remained unsolved for ten years despite eyewitness evidence, a suspect description, and DNA recovered from the crime scene.

Investigators spent years following leads that ultimately went nowhere. They questioned Dana’s husband, investigated a suspicious SUV, and even considered a man who falsely claimed responsibility for the attack.

The breakthrough came when Michael Pace finally decided to tell police what he knew about Jonathan Vick.

His information led investigators to obtain Jonathan’s DNA, which matched the evidence collected in 1995.

Dana was only 27 years old when her life was taken. She left behind a husband and two children, and her planned meeting with a divorce lawyer never took place.

Her case shows how important forensic evidence and witness cooperation can be in solving a murder, even when years have passed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *